Soft Starters Working, types, applications
Soft starters work by regulating the voltage supplied to the motor during start-up. This is achieved by using thyristors or Silicon-controlled rectifiers (SCRs) that gradually increase the voltage from zero to full operational levels. By controlling the voltage, soft starters help reduce the current and limit the torque surge, ensuring a smooth starting process.
An electrical device called a soft starter controls the acceleration and deceleration of an electric motor. .It provides a gradual increase in voltage during starting, reducing mechanical stress and power surges. Soft starters are widely used in industrial applications where controlled motor startup is essential for the efficiency and longevity of the system.
Components of Soft starter
A soft starter typically consists of:
1-Power electronics (SCRs or Thyristors):
What are SCRs or Thyristors?
SCRs, or Silicon-controlled Rectifiers, are four-layer semiconductor devices (PNPN structure) that act as electronic switches. They can control large amounts of power with small triggering signals. When a small voltage is applied to the gate terminal, the SCR allows current to flow between its anode and cathode until the current drops below a certain threshold or is interrupted externally.
Structure of an SCR
An SCR consists of three main terminals:
Anode (A) – the main positive terminal.
Cathode (K) – the main negative terminal.
Gate (G) – the control terminal that triggers the SCR.
Role of SCRs in Soft Starters
Soft starters use pairs of SCRs connected in a parallel-opposite configuration for each phase of a three-phase motor. These SCRs gradually apply voltage to the motor, ensuring a smooth and controlled acceleration.
Working principle of SCRs in soft starters
Initial state: At startup, the SCRs are in a non-conductive state, blocking the full supply voltage.
Phase-controlled firing: A controlled trigger pulse is applied to the gate terminals of the SCRs. This allows partial delivery of voltage to the motor, gradually increasing the voltage.
Gradual voltage increase: As the SCRs are energized earlier in each AC cycle, the voltage applied to the motor gradually increases, reducing the current and preventing mechanical stress.
Full voltage application: Once the motor reaches full speed, the SCRs are fully energized, passing the full voltage. In some designs, the SCRs are bypassed using connectors to reduce heat dissipation and improve efficiency.
Shutdown: During motor shutdown, SCRs gradually reduce the voltage to provide a soft stop, preventing mechanical shock and power surges.
Benefits of using SCRs in soft starters
Controlled start and stop: Prevents sudden shocks and mechanical stress in motors.
Low inrush current: Limits excessive current draw, preventing disruption to the electrical network.
Improved motor lifespan: Reduces thermal and mechanical wear, increasing motor longevity.
Energy efficiency: Reduces power surges and losses during start-up.
Compact and reliable: SCR-based soft starters offer high reliability with minimal maintenance.
Challenges and Considerations
While SCRs offer many advantages over soft starters, there are some considerations:
Heat Dissipation: SCRs generate heat during operation, requiring a heat sink or cooling system.
Harmonic Generation: Can introduce harmonics into the power system, requiring a filtering solution.
Complex Control Circuitry: Requires accurate gate triggering for optimal performance.
2-Microcontroller or logic controller:
The heart of the soft starter is the microcontroller unit (MCU), which is responsible for processing data and executing control commands. The MCU typically includes the following sub-components:
Central Processing Unit (CPU): Executes control algorithms and processes input/output data.
Memory (RAM, ROM, Flash): Stores program instructions and real-time data.
Clock Generator: Maintains synchronization of operations within the system.
Interrupt Controller: Manages high-priority events such as overcurrent detection.
1-Analog-to-Digital Converter (ADC)
The ADC is required to convert analog signals from voltage and current sensors into digital data that the MCU can process. These changes help the microcontroller monitor:
Input voltage levels
Motor current
Thermal sensor readings
2-Digital-to-analog converter (DAC)
Some soft starters use DACs to generate control signals for the power electronics. The DAC helps provide a smooth voltage ramp for motor acceleration and deceleration.
3-Pulse-width modulation (PWM) generator
PWM signals are used to control the firing angles of thyristors (SCRs) or Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistors (IGBTs) in the soft starter circuit. The microcontroller adjusts the PWM duty cycle to gradually increase or decrease the motor voltage, thereby reducing mechanical stress and power surges.
4-Communication interfaces
Modern soft starters integrate various communication protocols to enable remote monitoring and control. Common communication interfaces include:
For serial connections to external devices, use Universal Asynchronous Receiver-Transmitter, or UART.
SPI (Serial Peripheral Interface): Facilitates high-speed data exchange with sensors and peripherals.
I2C (Inter-Integrated Circuit): Connects low-speed peripheral devices.
Modbus/Profibus: Industry standard protocol for industrial automation systems.
5-Timers and Counters
Timers and counters are important for:
Accurate timing of control signals.
Creating time delays for smooth startup and shutdown.
Measuring pulse width in feedback signals.
6-Protection and Safety Features
The microcontroller ensures motor protection through various protection mechanisms, including:
Overcurrent protection: Shutting down or limiting power when excessive current is detected.
Overvoltage and undervoltage protection: Preventing damage due to voltage fluctuations.
Thermal protection: Monitoring temperature sensors to prevent overheating.
Fault diagnostics: Logging faults and triggering alarms for maintenance alerts.
3-Bypass contactor:
A bypass contactor is an electromechanical switching device within a soft starter system. Its primary function is to bypass the soft starter circuitry when the motor has successfully reached its nominal speed. This reduces energy losses, increases efficiency, and extends the life of the soft starter components.
Components of a Bypass Contactor
The bypass contactor consists of several key components, each playing a specific role in ensuring smooth and reliable motor operation.
1-Main Contacts
Once the soft start phase is complete, the main contacts are responsible for delivering high-power electrical current to the motor.
These contacts close when the soft starter signals that the motor has reached full speed, allowing current to flow directly from the power supply to the motor.
They are made of materials that have high conductivity and resistance to arcing, such as silver or silver alloys.
2-Coil (Electromagnet)
The coil is an integral component that controls the operation of the bypass contactor.
When energized, it creates a magnetic field that attracts and closes the main contacts, enabling the flow of current.
It operates at a predetermined voltage, typically 24V, 110V, or 230V AC/DC, depending on the application.
3-Arc Chutes
Arc chutes are designed to extinguish the electric arcs that are generated when the main contacts open or close.
They consist of metal plates or ceramic materials that help dissipate energy, preventing excessive wear on the contacts.
Efficient arc chutes improve the longevity of the bypass contactor.
4-Auxiliary Contacts
These are low-power contacts used for signaling and control purposes.
They provide feedback to the control system, indicating whether the bypass contactor is engaged or disengaged.
Auxiliary contacts are commonly used in automation and monitoring systems.
5-Spring mechanism
A spring-loaded mechanism ensures that the contacts return to their original position when the coil is de-energized.
This plays a vital role in ensuring reliable operation, preventing accidental contact closure or bounce.
6-Housing and insulation
The bypass contactor is enclosed in an insulating, fire-resistant housing to protect internal components and personnel from electrical hazards.
This ensures compliance with safety regulations and increases the durability of the system.
Function of the bypass contactor in a soft starter
Starting phase
When the motor is started, the soft starter gradually increases the voltage to reduce inrush current and mechanical stress.
Bypass Activation
Once the motor reaches full speed, the bypass contactor is activated, which closes the main contacts and allows full current to flow directly into the motor.
Energy Efficiency and Conservation
The bypass contactor helps reduce heat generation in the soft starter’s power electronics, preventing overheating and increasing overall efficiency.
Shutdown Process
When the motor is stopped, the bypass contactor is disconnected, and the soft starter can control idling if necessary.
Benefits of Using a Bypass Contactor
Reduces Power Losses: Limits Heat Dissipation in the Soft Starter by Allowing Direct Current to Flow.
Extends Soft Starter Lifespan: Prevents Continuous Operation of Semiconductor Components, Reducing Thermal Stress.
Increases System Reliability: Ensures Smooth Transition Between Start-up and Full-Speed ​​Operation.
Improves energy efficiency: Reduces power losses and increases overall motor efficiency.
4-Protection mechanisms:
1-Overload Protection
Overload protection protects the motor from excessive current draw, which can cause overheating and damage. Soft starters include built-in thermal overload protection, which often works by:
Electronic overload relays: These monitor the motor current and trip when it exceeds a predetermined limit.
Thermal modeling algorithms: Some modern soft starters calculate the thermal state of the motor based on real-time current data.
2-Short-circuit protection
Short circuits can be caused by insulation failure, mechanical faults, or wiring problems. Soft starters implement short-circuit protection using:
Fuses: High-speed semiconductor fuses designed to prevent excessive current flow.
Circuit breakers: Used as an additional safety mechanism to prevent excessive fault current from damaging the system.
Current sensors: These continuously monitor the current and disconnect the supply if a short circuit condition is detected.
3-Phase loss and phase imbalance protection
Unbalanced phase current can cause the motor to overheat and reduce efficiency. Soft starters detect phase imbalance:
Phase monitoring relays: These measure voltage and current imbalance, triggering an alarm or shutdown if significant deviations are detected.
Phase sequence monitoring: Ensures that the motor receives the correct phase sequence to prevent reverse rotation, which can damage mechanical equipment.
4-Undervoltage and overvoltage protection
Voltage fluctuations can adversely affect the performance of the motor. Soft starters include:
Voltage sensing circuits: Detect abnormal voltage levels and trigger shutdown when the voltage exceeds safe operating limits.
Programmable Voltage Limit: Users can set voltage limits to prevent excessive stress on the motor and electrical system.
5-Stall Protection
A stall occurs when a motor fails to reach its rated speed, often due to excessive load or mechanical failure. Soft starters include:
Torque and speed monitoring: Ensures high motor speeds.
Preset stall time settings: Trips the starter if the motor remains in a stalled state for longer than a safe period.
6-Overtemperature protection
Temperature sensors, such as PTC (positive temperature coefficient) thermistors or RTDs (resistance temperature detectors), monitor the motor and soft starter temperatures. If excessive heat is detected, the soft starter will:
Reduce the load or adjust the startup parameters.
Initiate shutdown to prevent thermal damage.
7-Ground Fault Protection
A ground fault occurs when current leaks to ground due to insulation failure. Soft starters use:
Leakage current sensors: Detect small deviations in current.
Automatic shutdown features: When a ground fault is detected, disconnect the power supply, preventing electrical hazards.
8-Communication and diagnostic features
Modern soft starters include communication protocols such as Modbus, Profibus, and Ethernet/IP to provide:
Remote monitoring and control: Real-time data on motor performance and faults.
Event logging and diagnostics: Stores fault history for analysis and troubleshooting.
Types of soft starter
Soft starters can be classified based on their operational methods:
1-Voltage ramp soft starters:
What is a voltage ramp soft starter?
A voltage ramp soft starter is a type of motor soft starter that gradually increases the supply voltage to an electric motor, allowing it to start smoothly without excessive inrush current. This method prevents mechanical and electrical stress, extending the life of the motor and associated components.
Working principle
Voltage ramp soft starters work by gradually increasing the voltage supplied to the motor over a set period of time. This is achieved using thyristors (SCRs) that control the phase angle of the voltage applied to the motor. The voltage is increased in a controlled manner from a low initial value to the full supply voltage, ensuring a fast acceleration process.
The ramp-up time and the initial voltage level can be adjusted according to the application requirements. Some modern soft starters also incorporate current feedback mechanisms to improve performance based on the load conditions of the motor.
Key Features and Benefits
1-Smooth Motor Start-up
Reduces mechanical stress on motor and drive components.
Reduces torque surges, protecting gears and belts.
2-Low inrush current
Prevents voltage drops in electrical systems.
Helps prevent tripping of circuit breakers and fuses.
3-Energy efficiency
Limits power surges, reducing energy consumption during startup.
Increases overall system efficiency.
4-Extended equipment life
Reduces wear and tear on motor windings.
Prevents excessive heating of electrical components.
5-Configurable settings
Adjust ramp time and starting voltage level.
Customizable for different motor types and applications.
Applications of Voltage Ramp Soft Starters
Voltage ramp soft starters are used in various industries where controlled motor start-up is essential. Some common applications include:
1-Pumps
Reduces the effect of water hammer in pipeline systems.
Protects pump seals and impellers from sudden pressure surges.
2-Fans and blowers
Prevents sudden torque effects that can damage blades and bearings.
3-Conveyors
Ensures smooth starting, prevents material splashing and belt slippage.
4-Compressors
Reduces mechanical stress, extends the life of compressor units.
5-Mixers and agitators
Allows gradual acceleration, prevents sudden movement and mechanical failure.
Considerations When Selecting a Voltage Ramp Soft Starter
When selecting a voltage ramp soft starter for an application, the following factors should be considered:
1-Motor power rating
Ensure compatibility with the motor voltage and current ratings.
2-Ramp time and starting voltage
Select appropriate ramp settings based on load characteristics.
3-Environmental conditions
Consider ambient temperature, humidity, and exposure to dust or moisture.
4-Protection features
Look for built-in overload protection, phase loss detection, and thermal monitoring.
5-Integration with control systems
Ensure compatibility with PLCs or remote monitoring systems, if required.
2-Current limit soft starters:
What is a current limit soft starter?
A current limit soft starter is a type of soft starter designed to limit the starting current of an electric motor to a predetermined maximum value. Unlike voltage ramp soft starters that gradually increase the voltage to the motor, current limit soft starters focus on keeping the current below a specified limit to prevent overloads of the electrical system.
Working Principle
The operation of a current limit soft starter is based on monitoring and controlling the current drawn by the motor during startup. This is achieved by:
Thyristor Control – The starter uses power electronics, such as Silicon Controlled Rectifiers (SCRs), to regulate the voltage supplied to the motor.
Feedback Mechanism – A closed-loop feedback system continuously measures the motor current and adjusts the SCR firing angle to maintain the desired current level.
Gradual acceleration – By controlling the current, the motor experiences a smooth and controlled acceleration, reducing mechanical and electrical stress.
Benefits of current limit soft starters
Reduced electrical stress – Limits high inrush currents, protecting electrical networks from voltage drops and system failures.
Improved motor protection – Prevents overheating and excessive wear on motor windings.
Energy efficiency – Reduces power surges and improves overall system efficiency.
Extended equipment life – Reduces mechanical stress on gearboxes, belts and couplings by enabling smooth acceleration.
Custom settings – Users can set specific current limits based on application requirements.
Applications of current limit soft starters.
Current limit soft starters are widely used in industries where precise current control is essential, such as:
Pumps and compressors – To reduce the effects of water hammer and avoid pressure surges.
Conveyor systems – To ensure smooth starting to prevent belt slippage and mechanical shocks.
Fans and blowers – To avoid excessive current draw that can damage the electrical infrastructure.
HVAC systems – To protect motors in heating, ventilation, and air conditioning setups.
Industrial machines – To improve operational efficiency in heavy-duty manufacturing processes.
Considerations for selecting a current limit soft starter
When selecting a current limit soft starter, the following factors should be considered:
Motor power rating – Ensure compatibility with the voltage and power requirements of the motor.
Current limit settings – Select a device with an adjustable current limit for flexibility in different applications.
Environmental conditions – Consider temperature, humidity, and potential exposure to dust or corrosive elements.
Integration with control systems – Check compatibility with PLCs, automation systems, and remote monitoring.
Protection features – Look for pre-existing safety measures such as overload protection, phase loss detection, and thermal monitoring.
3-Torque control soft starters:
Torque controls the operation of soft starters by regulating the voltage applied to the motor in a way that directly affects the torque produced. This is achieved by using phase angle controlled thyristors (SCRs) that gradually increase the motor voltage, preventing sudden torque spikes.
Unlike traditional voltage ramp soft starters, torque control soft starters use a feedback mechanism that continuously adjusts the output based on motor load conditions. Advanced algorithms ensure consistent torque application, improving system efficiency and reducing mechanical stress on associated machinery.
Key Features and Benefits
Smooth motor startup and shutdown:
Eliminates sudden torque surges that can damage gears, belts and other mechanical components.
Reduces electrical stress on motor windings.
Low Inrush Current:
Limits excessive current draw during startup, preventing voltage sags in electrical systems.
Increases system stability and extends the life of electrical components.
Improved motor protection:
Provides protection against overload, underload, phase failure, and overheating.
Helps prevent damage to motor windings and insulation due to sudden torque variations.
Energy efficiency:
Reduces energy consumption by improving motor efficiency.
Reduces power losses associated with excessive torque application.
Adaptability to load variations:
Suitable for both constant and variable torque loads.
Ensures optimal performance in conveyor systems, pumps, fans, and compressors.
Applications of Torque Control Soft Starters
Torque control soft starters are widely used in industries where smooth and controlled motor startup is essential. Typical applications include:
Pumps and Fans: Prevents water hammer and mechanical shock in fluid handling systems.
Conveyors: Ensures smooth material handling without any jolts.
Compressors: Reduces mechanical wear during motor startup.
Mixers and Agitators: Provides controlled acceleration to prevent sudden movement.
HVAC Systems: Increases energy efficiency and motor longevity in air handling units.
Selection Criteria for Torque Control Soft Starters
When selecting a torque control soft starter, several factors should be considered:
Motor Specifications: Ensure compatibility with motor power rating, voltage, and current requirements.
Load Type: Identify whether the application requires constant or variable torque control.
Control Features: Look for advanced features such as programmable start/stop profiles, remote monitoring, and integrated motor protection.
Environmental conditions: Consider ambient temperature, humidity, and enclosure rating (IP rating) for reliable operation.
Integration with automation systems: Ensure compatibility with existing PLCs, SCADA, or IoT-based monitoring systems.
4-Hybrid soft starters:
A hybrid soft starter is a device that uses both solid-state (electronic) and electromechanical (contactor) switching elements to control the inrush current and torque during motor startup. The electronic part handles the initial phase of startup, reducing stress on the motor and electrical system, while the mechanical contactors take over once the motor reaches the desired speed to reduce heat dissipation and energy loss.
How Hybrid Soft Starters Work
Hybrid soft starters work in the following sequence:
Initial startup phase: The soft starter uses thyristors (SCRs) to gradually increase the voltage applied to the motor, ensuring a smooth ramp-up.
Transition to Bypass Mode: Once the motor reaches rated speed, the control system activates the electromechanical bypass contactor, allowing full voltage operation with minimal heat generation.
Normal Operation: The contactor remains engaged, eliminating the need for continuous thyristor conduction, reducing energy consumption and increasing efficiency.
Shutdown Phase: The starter uses electronic switching to provide controlled deceleration to prevent mechanical stress on the system.
Advantages of Hybrid Soft Starters
Hybrid soft starters offer several advantages over traditional electronic or electromechanical soft starters:
1-Reduced heat generation
Since the thyristors are only active during startup and shutdown, heat dissipation is significantly reduced compared to full-time electronic soft starters.
2-Improved energy efficiency
By using mechanical contactors during normal operation, hybrid soft starters consume less power than purely electronic solutions.
3-Extended component life
Minimal heat generation reduces wear and tear on electronic components, extending the lifespan of the soft starter.
4-Smooth motor acceleration and deceleration
Controlled voltage ramp-up and ramp-down prevent sudden torque fluctuations, reduce mechanical stress and extend motor longevity.
5-Lower maintenance requirements
Since thyristors are only used temporarily, there is less need for cooling systems and frequent maintenance compared to fully electronic soft starters.
Applications of Hybrid Soft Starters
Hybrid soft starters are widely used in various industries due to their efficiency and reliability. Some key applications include:
1-Pumps
Reduces water hammer effects by ensuring smooth acceleration and deceleration.
Prevents excessive inrush current in large industrial pumps.
2-Compressors
Limits electrical stress and extends compressor life.
Improves system stability by reducing current spikes.
3-Conveyor Systems
Ensures smooth start and stop cycles while minimizing mechanical wear.
Prevents sudden torque surges that can damage conveyor belts.
4-Fans and Blowers
Provides gradual starts to prevent electrical overloads.
Reduces noise and vibration associated with sudden starts.
5-HVAC Systems
Helps manage start-up current in large heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems.
Increases operational efficiency and reduces electrical stress.
Advantages of soft starter
Low mechanical stress: Limits sudden torque changes, protecting motor components.
Low electrical stress: Prevents high-speed currents, reducing power surges.
Extended equipment life: Reduces wear and tear on motors and connected systems.
Energy efficiency: Some models improve power utilization, reducing energy consumption.
Smooth operation: Eliminates sudden starts and stops, improving system stability.
Applications of soft starter
Soft starters are used in a variety of industries, including:
Pumps: Prevent water hammer effects in pipelines.
Fans and blowers: Ensure controlled air flow.
Conveyors: Reduce shock during startup, protecting equipment.
Compressors: Increase efficiency in air and gas compression.
HVAC systems: Easily control air conditioning systems.
Soft Starter vs. Variable Frequency Drive (VFD)
While both soft starters and variable frequency drives (VFDs) control motor operation, they serve different purposes:
Soft starter: Controls only the start and stop phase, not speed regulation.
VFD: Provides complete motor speed control and torque regulation.
If the application only requires a controlled start, a soft starter is ideal. However, if continuous speed changes are required, a VFD is the better option.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is a soft starter?
Answer:
An electronic device known as a soft starter is used to gradually increase the voltage supplied to an electric motor, enabling a smooth start and minimizing mechanical stress and electrical peak currents.
Â
2. Why use a soft starter instead of a direct-on-line (DOL) starter?
Answer:
By reducing inrush current and mechanical stress, a soft starter aids in prolonging motor life, decreasing downtime, and minimizing wear on connected equipment.
3. How does a soft starter work?
Answer:
It operates by managing the voltage provided to the motor with SCRs (silicon-controlled rectifiers) or thyristors, incrementally raising the voltage as it starts up.
4. What types of motors are suitable for soft starters?
Answer:
Three-phase AC induction motors are the usual application for soft starters.
5. Can soft starters be used with single-phase motors?
Answer:
Most soft starters cater to three-phase motors. There are, however, specialized models designed for single-phase motors.
6. What are the main benefits of using a soft starter?
Answer:
1-Reduced mechanical wear
2-Lower inrush current
3-Extended equipment life
4-Smooth acceleration
5-Energy savings during startup
7. What applications commonly use soft starters?
Answer:
Pumps, fans, compressors, conveyors, mixers, and HVAC systems utilize them.
8. What's the difference between a soft starter and a VFD (Variable Frequency Drive)?
Answer:
While a soft starter regulates voltage solely during the startup phase, a VFD manages both speed and torque for the duration of the motor’s operation by adjusting frequency.
9. Can soft starters provide motor protection?
Answer:
Yes, many soft starters come with features such as overload protection, phase loss protection, and under/over-voltage protection.
10. Do soft starters improve energy efficiency?
Answer:
While they enhance energy utilization during startup, they do not match the energy efficiency of VFDs in continuous operation.
